Starkey & Mueller

PM Team FULL Show 5-14-26

Cherington’s Chatter – What did Ben Cherington say to the media? Pirates insider Jason Mackey joined the show. Jason reacted to a Pirates series win over the Rockies. The Pirates started Endy Rodriguez, who immediately provided as much offense as Henry Davis has all season. Jason thinks if Endy hits, he will play, even though Davis provides the good defense. Jason thinks Carmen Mlodzinski heads to the bullpen when Jared Jones returns, even though he’s arguably been better than Bubba Chandler this season. Jason described Jones as ‘intense’ after a report about how he was handling questions after his rehab start in Altoona. Did the one blown save from Dennis Santana crush his legacy with Don Kelly? The guys asked Jason about Konnor Griffin moving about the lineup. Is Pittsburgh a ‘mediocre’ baseball town? Jason said the team has to earn the trust of the fans since we have only witnessed 3 playoff teams in 30+ years. Name Game.

Did the entire Steelers schedule get leaked? Is it true that the Pirates have the 6th most-expensive ticket in baseball? It can’t be, right? Is it fair to put the pressure on the fans for not showing up in big numbers at the ballpark? Manager’s Minute – What did Don Kelly say after today’s game?

Drew Allar is going under a total reboot courtesy of Mike McCarthy. Is that a bad sign for the rookie QB? What does it say about the teachings at Penn State? If Aaron Rodgers is their guy this year, when will we really know if this work has paid off for Allar? The guys don’t want that to impact their plans in the 2027 NFL Draft. KDKA TV’s Bob Pompeani joined the show. We reacted as the Pirates defeated the Rockies, 7-2, to take the series at PNC Park. Bob credited Endy Rodriguez for his work in the first game of the season, getting 2 hits in his 2026 debut. Bob said he’s not a fan of the ‘opener’ method, but it worked out for Don Kelly and his club today. What do we think the future looks like for Jared Jones that is working through his rehab assignment? Attendance of over 19k today in the afternoon finale at PNC Park just days after barely 13k watched Paul Skenes dazzle. Pomp said fans have good reason to not be there in droves just yet after so much losing baseball in the last 3 decades. The guys peppered

Pirates insider Jason Mackey joined the show. Jason reacted to a Pirates series win over the Rockies. The Pirates started Endy Rodriguez, who immediately provided as much offense as Henry Davis has all season. Jason thinks if Endy hits, he will play, even though Davis provides the good defense. Jason thinks Carmen Mlodzinski heads to the bullpen when Jared Jones returns, even though he’s arguably been better than Bubba Chandler this season. Jason described Jones as ‘intense’ after a report about how he was handling questions after his rehab start in Altoona. Did the one blown save from Dennis Santana crush his legacy with Don Kelly? The guys asked Jason about Konnor Griffin moving about the lineup. Is Pittsburgh a ‘mediocre’ baseball town? Jason said the team has to earn the trust of the fans since we have only witnessed 3 playoff teams in 30+ years.

KDKA TV’s Bob Pompeani joined the show. We reacted as the Pirates defeated the Rockies, 7-2, to take the series at PNC Park. Bob credited Endy Rodriguez for his work in the first game of the season, getting 2 hits in his 2026 debut. Bob said he’s not a fan of the ‘opener’ method, but it worked out for Don Kelly and his club today. What do we think the future looks like for Jared Jones that is working through his rehab assignment? Attendance of over 19k today in the afternoon finale at PNC Park just days after barely 13k watched Paul Skenes dazzle. Pomp said fans have good reason to not be there in droves just yet after so much losing baseball in the last 3 decades. The guys peppered Bob on a few questions about the NFL schedule.

Drew Allar is going under a total reboot courtesy of Mike McCarthy. Is that a bad sign for the rookie QB? What does it say about the teachings at Penn State? If Aaron Rodgers is their guy this year, when will we really know if this work has paid off for Allar? The guys don’t want that to impact their plans in the 2027 NFL Draft.

It is NFL Schedule Release day. What do we know so far? The thrill is in the chase as we try to piece together the Steelers schedule before it officially gets unveiled at 8 pm.

PM Team FULL Show 5-13-26

Aaron Rodgers fooled a lot of people into thinking he was still an elite QB after week 1 last year. Is there really still a point in Rodgers returning to Pittsburgh this year. Poni does not think the Steelers will tell the truth about anything Aaron Rodgers related right now. He thinks that they are scared that they will offend Rodgers. Mullsy thinks that this is pathetic on the Steelers’ end. ALL ACCESS w/ Aditi – Aditi thinks it weird that Rodgers would come to Pittsburgh and not meet with anybody in the Steelers organization. She questions if he was ever actually here at all. She also says that part of the reason why the Steelers hired McCarthy is his ability to develop quarterbacks. Allar said at the combine that Mike McCarthy was the most interesting interaction he had. Donny Football Debrief – The Packers and Rams will play on Netflix on Thanksgiving Eve.

The Steelers will play the Saints in Paris this season. The estimated cost for this whole trip is about $4000-$5000. The guys think that there will be a bunch of Steelers fans that make the trip out to France, and that it will be a similar crowd to the games that are played in London. Donny is hearing that the Steelers are rumored to be playing on Christmas against the Buccaneers in Tampa Bay. This feels like a weird game to be played on Christmas, at least according to the guys. The Steelers have apparently uninstalled basically every one of Drew Allar’s QB mechanics. Allar is moving through drills at half-speed right now. Poni thinks that Allar will be QB3, and that Will Howard will have to prove that he is ready to be Aaron Rodgers’ backup. Mike Florio from Pro Football Talk joined the show. Aaron Rodgers came to Pittsburgh without telling anybody within the Steelers organization just to play golf. The Steelers never even knew where he was. Mike thinks that Rodgers is overestimating how much interest o

Another gem from Paul Skenes as the Pirates beat the Rockies, 3-1 at PNC Park. Skenes tossed 8 scoreless innings for the second consecutive start and carried a no-hitter into the 7th inning. A footnote from the game is the lack of people in the crowd. There were only around 13k tickets sold and fewer than that in the building. It spurred comments about Pittsburgh being a ‘mediocre’ baseball town from a retired Pittsburgh sports writer. Is he right? Is it a blackeye on the fans to not have a bigger number at the ballpark? The guys defended Pittsburghers on this one. The Pirates drew 31,000+ fans per game in 2015. Is Pittsburgh a good or lousy baseball town? Former Penguin Tyler Kennedy joined the show. TK is a member at a local golf course that was rumored to be visited by Aaron Rodgers this weekend, but he didn’t have confirmation on that. Will Evgeni Malkin be back? Does Kyle Dubas have something up his sleeve once we hit free agency? With how much power Sidney Crosby has over the organization, how does

93.7 The Fan Sports Director Jeff Hathhorn joined the show. Jeff reacted to Konnor Griffin moving up to #2 in the lineup tonight as the Buccos play a lefty. If Marcel Ozuna doesn’t pick it up by month’s end, is he in trouble of losing his role entirely? There’s an update on Jared Jones and it’s that he is refusing to answer questions about pitching out of the bullpen. Jeff didn’t want to criticize fans for not being at the ballpark last night due to the current economic climate.

Donny Football Debrief – The Packers and Rams will play on Netflix on Thanksgiving Eve.

Aaron Rodgers fooled a lot of people into thinking he was still an elite QB after week 1 last year. Is there really still a point in Rodgers returning to Pittsburgh this year. Poni does not think the Steelers will tell the truth about anything Aaron Rodgers related right now. He thinks that they are scared that they will offend Rodgers. Mullsy thinks that this is pathetic on the Steelers’ end.

Mike Florio from Pro Football Talk joined the show. Aaron Rodgers came to Pittsburgh without telling anybody within the Steelers organization just to play golf. The Steelers never even knew where he was. Mike thinks that Rodgers is overestimating how much interest other organizations would have in him if their QB position were to become open. It is also obvious that the Cardinals are not interested in Rodgers. Florio says that the Steelers are not realistically built to actually compete this year. Mike thinks that there will be a lot of Steelers fans that go to France this year.

The Steelers will play the Saints in Paris this season. The estimated cost for this whole trip is about $4000-$5000. The guys think that there will be a bunch of Steelers fans that make the trip out to France, and that it will be a similar crowd to the games that are played in London. Donny is hearing that the Steelers are rumored to be playing on Christmas against the Buccaneers in Tampa Bay. This feels like a weird game to be played on Christmas, at least according to the guys.

Name Game

Another gem from Paul Skenes as the Pirates beat the Rockies, 3-1 at PNC Park. Skenes tossed 8 scoreless innings for the second consecutive start and carried a no-hitter into the 7th inning. A footnote from the game is the lack of people in the crowd. There were only around 13k tickets sold and fewer than that in the building. It spurred comments about Pittsburgh being a ‘mediocre’ baseball town from a retired Pittsburgh sports writer. Is he right? Is it a blackeye on the fans to not have a bigger number at the ballpark? The guys defended Pittsburghers on this one. The Pirates drew 31,000+ fans per game in 2015.