Starkey & Mueller

Hour 1: Donny Football back in for the guys on the first day of 2026! The last half-decade hasn’t been good for Pittsburgh sports. Which Pittsburgh team is closest to a championship right now? And Jason Mackey joins the show to give a look at the Pirates’ and Penguins’ new year outlook. Hour 2: Donny gives his New Year’s resolutions for the Pittsburgh sports teams. Bob Pompeani once met Ryan Seacrest. And who are the most hated Ravens in the Pittsburgh-Baltimore rivalry? Hour 3: Nick Farabaugh and Steve Palazzalo join the show to talk the latest Steelers and NFL news. Dom wants the Rose Bowl to be the site of the national championship game every year. And the guys wonder what the best outcome is for Georgia-Ole Miss tonight. Hour 4: Donny is very excited for today's Rocky anniversary. Ray Fittipaldo joins the show to preview Steelers-Ravens. And the guys try to figure out what happened to WWE's library that disappeared from Peacock.

Hour 4: Donny is very excited for today's Rocky anniversary. Ray Fittipaldo joins the show to preview Steelers-Ravens. And the guys try to figure out what happened to WWE's library that disappeared from Peacock.

Hour 3: Nick Farabaugh and Steve Palazzalo join the show to talk the latest Steelers and NFL news. Dom wants the Rose Bowl to be the site of the national championship game every year. And the guys wonder what the best outcome is for Georgia-Ole Miss tonight.

Dom can’t believe we still don’t have the Rose Bowl as the site of the national championship game. Why is the Cotton Bowl Classic not played at the Cotton? What’s the better outcome of tonight’s Sugar Bowl, getting Carson Beck vs. Georgia or a Lane Kiffin-less Ole Miss team making a run? How in the world did Beck pull a Cavinder twin?

Hour 2: Donny gives his New Year’s resolutions for the Pittsburgh sports teams. Bob Pompeani once met Ryan Seacrest. And who are the most hated Ravens in the Pittsburgh-Baltimore rivalry?

Bob Pompeani joins the show to talk about hosting a New Year’s show on KDKA back in the day, what it was like meeting Dick Clark and Ryan Seacrest once, if Pomp could host a game show, Oregon’s win over Texas Tech in the Orange Bowl, what he expects to see in Steelers-Ravens on Sunday, if TJ Watt will play this weekend, if he’ll watch the Rose Bowl in a little bit, what the second-most prestigious bowl game is, and more!

Hour 1: Donny Football back in for the guys on the first day of 2026! The last half-decade hasn’t been good for Pittsburgh sports. Which Pittsburgh team is closest to a championship right now? And Jason Mackey joins the show to give a look at the Pirates’ and Penguins’ new year outlook.

Jason Mackey joins the show to talk about which Pittsburgh team is closest to a title, what the Pirates will do at third base, what the Buccos will do with Andrew McCutchen, if Jake Mangum will get a significant role in Pittsburgh, who the starting shortstop will be, the youth movement on the Penguins, and more!

Hour 1: Donny Football in for the guys on this New Year’s Eve! Does Donny want Lamar Jackson to play in Sunday’s Steelers-Ravens game? Tyler Kennedy joins the show to talk about the Penguins’ recent wins and trade. And Donny wants Tostitos to return as the sponsor of the Fiesta Bowl. Hour 2: Donny looks back on the 2025 resolutions he gave the Pittsburgh sports teams at the beginning of the year. Matt Clement joins the show to talk about the Pirates’ offseason so far. And Mike Florio jumps on with Donny to talk about Week 18, Mike Tomlin as a TV analyst, possible NFL seeding changes, and more. Hour 3: Dom has an issue with the TV setup Donny has in the studio. Donny gives his 2025 Pittsburgh athlete Mount Rushmore. And Aditi Kinkhabwala and Jeff Hathhorn join the show to go over all the latest football and Steelers news. Hour 4: We listen to Aaron Rodgers’ comments from his press conference today. Dom almost got into a bar fight last night. And the guys reminisce on old WWE PPVs that they miss.

Hour 4: We listen to Aaron Rodgers’ comments from his press conference today. Dom almost got into a bar fight last night. And the guys reminisce on old WWE PPVs that they miss.

Donny and Dom reflect on the different New Year’s that they are about to have. Dom wants us to appreciate Ryan Seacrest on this day. Who are the greatest hosts of all time? Donny loved when Regis Philbin hosted Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?. Dom almost got into a bar fight last night. Would Donny be good in a bar fight? What would a Fan producer bouncer lineup look like?

Hour 3: Dom has an issue with the TV setup Donny has in the studio. Donny gives his 2025 Pittsburgh athlete Mount Rushmore. And Aditi Kinkhabwala and Jeff Hathhorn join the show to go over all the latest football and Steelers news.

Why does Donny not have Michigan-Texas on a TV in the studio? Donny gives us his Mount Rushmore of Pittsburgh athletes in 2025.

Hour 2: Donny looks back on the 2025 resolutions he gave the Pittsburgh sports teams at the beginning of the year. Matt Clement joins the show to talk about the Pirates’ offseason so far. And Mike Florio jumps on with Donny to talk about Week 18, Mike Tomlin as a TV analyst, possible NFL seeding changes, and more.

Mike Florio joins the show to talk about his New Year’s Eve plans, if he likes how the Week 18 flex scheduling works, if the NFL made the right call with the prime time games this weekend, what the futures look like for Aaron Rodgers and Lamar Jackson, the prospect of Mike Tomlin as a TV analyst, who the Browns could get as their next head coach if they make a change, which big-name head coaches could be on the move, if the NFL could change its playoff seeding format, when we could get an 18-game season, if the league could expand beyond 32 teams, if Hines Ward should be in the Hall of Fame, and more! We love Florio as a guest.

Hour 1: Donny Football in for the guys on this New Year’s Eve! Does Donny want Lamar Jackson to play in Sunday’s Steelers-Ravens game? Tyler Kennedy joins the show to talk about the Penguins’ recent wins and trade. And Donny wants Tostitos to return as the sponsor of the Fiesta Bowl.

It’s New Year’s Eve and there’s a lot happening right now. What is the latest status update on TJ Watt and Lamar Jackson ahead of Sunday night’s Steelers-Ravens game? Donny says he is more scared of Tyler Huntley than Lamar. Donny says Pittsburgh can win this game without Watt.

How'd we get here, Tomlin Takes, and PM Team Name Game

The Final PM Team Name Game of the Year

Tomlin Takes